Working Paper: NBER ID: w29052
Authors: Nina Buchmann; Erica M. Field; Rachel Glennerster; Shahana Nazneen; Xiao Yu Wang
Abstract: Child marriage remains common even where female schooling and employment opportunities have grown. We introduce a signaling model in which bride type is imperfectly observed but preferred types have lower returns to delaying marriage. We show that in this environment the market might pool on early marriage even when everyone would benefit from delay. In this setting, offering a small incentive can delay marriage of all treated types and untreated non-preferred types, while programs that act directly on norms can unintentionally encourage early marriage. We test these theoretical predictions by experimentally evaluating a financial incentive to delay marriage alongside a girls’ empowerment program designed to shift norms. As predicted, girls eligible for the incentive are 19% less likely to marry underage, as are nonpreferred type women ineligible for the incentive. Meanwhile, the empowerment program was successful in promoting more progressive gender norms but failed to decrease adolescent marriage and increased dowry payments.
Keywords: Child Marriage; Financial Incentive; Gender Norms; Bangladesh
JEL Codes: D03; D9; O1
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| Empowerment Program (I24) | Marriage Timing (J12) |
| Empowerment Program (I24) | Dowry Payments (J12) |
| Signaling Effect (D85) | Non-Preferred Types Underage Marriage (J12) |
| Financial Incentives (G29) | Norm-Changing Programs Effectiveness (C90) |
| Financial Incentive (G29) | Delay in Marriage Age (J12) |
| Financial Incentive (G29) | Underage Marriage Rate (J12) |