Working Paper: NBER ID: w28962
Authors: Karen Clay; Akshaya Jha; Joshua A. Lewis; Edson R. Severnini
Abstract: This study leverages newly digitized data on virtually every fossil-fuel power plant in the United States from 1938-1994 to provide the first assessment of the impacts of the 1970 Clean Air Act (CAA) that accounts for anticipation. The extended pre-regulation benchmark allows us to account for anticipatory behavior by electric utilities in the years leading up to the Act's passage. Guided by predictions from a simple theoretical framework, we use a difference-in-differences approach to examine the impacts of the Act's nonattainment designations on coal-fired power plants of different vintages. We find that nonattainment designation led to large and persistent decreases in plant productivity, which would be substantially underestimated without data from well before the passage of the 1970 CAA. The productivity losses were concentrated only among plants built before 1963. This timing aligns with the passage of the original 1963 CAA, which served as a signal of impending federal regulation. We provide empirical and historical evidence of anticipatory responses by utilities in the design and siting of plants that opened after 1963. Finally, we find that the aggregate productivity losses of the CAA borne by the power sector were substantially mitigated by the reallocation of output away from older less productive power plants.
Keywords: Clean Air Act; Power Sector; Anticipation; Adaptation
JEL Codes: K32; N52; N72; Q41; Q48; Q52; Q58
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| Nonattainment designation (Q52) | 14% reduction in productivity for coal-fired plants (L94) |
| 1963 CAA (C42) | preemptive adjustments in operations by electric utilities (L97) |
| 1963 CAA (C42) | changes in plant design (increased stack heights, pollution abatement technologies) (Q52) |
| Reallocation of output from older plants to newer ones (L23) | mitigation of aggregate productivity losses from CAA (O49) |
| CAA (Z28) | annual total productivity loss of about $26 billion (2020 USD) (J17) |
| 1963 CAA (C42) | anticipatory behavior of plants built before 1970 CAA (Q52) |