Neighborhoods Matter: Assessing the Evidence for Place Effects

Working Paper: NBER ID: w28953

Authors: Eric Chyn; Lawrence F. Katz

Abstract: How does one's place of residence affect individual behavior and long-run outcomes? Understanding neighborhood and place effects has been a leading question for social scientists during the past half-century. Recent empirical studies using experimental and quasi-experimental research designs have generated new insights on the importance of residential neighborhoods in childhood and adulthood. This paper summarizes the recent neighborhood effects literature and interprets the findings. Childhood neighborhoods affect long-run economic and educational outcomes in a manner consistent with exposure models of neighborhood effects. For adults, neighborhood environments matter for their health and well-being but have more ambiguous impacts on labor market outcomes. We discuss the evidence on the mechanisms behind the observed patterns and conclude by highlighting directions for future research.

Keywords: neighborhood effects; place effects; economic outcomes; educational outcomes

JEL Codes: H75; I38; R23


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
childhood neighborhoods (R23)long-run economic outcomes (P17)
childhood neighborhoods (R23)long-run educational outcomes (I26)
moving to neighborhoods with advantageous attributes (R23)greater benefits (H43)
neighborhood environments (R23)adult health and well-being (I19)
neighborhood environments (R23)labor market outcomes (J48)
long-distance relocations (J62)positive economic results (F69)
neighborhood poverty (I32)individual outcomes (I14)
neighborhood characteristics (e.g., poverty rates) (R23)various outcomes (e.g., employment, health, education) (I26)
school quality, peer influences, exposure to violence (I24)neighborhood effects (R23)

Back to index