Working Paper: NBER ID: w28403
Authors: Ruixue Jia; Grard Roland; Yang Xie
Abstract: Despite a large consensus among economists on the strong interdependence and synergy between pro-development institutions, how should one understand why Imperial China, with weaker rule of law and property rights, gave the commoners more opportunities to access elite status than Premodern Europe, for example via the civil service exam and the absence of hereditary titles? Supported by rich historical narratives, we show that these institutional differences reflect more general differences in the power structure of society: (1) the Ruler enjoyed weaker absolute power in Europe; (2) the People were more on par with the Elites in China in terms of power and rights. Based on these narratives, we build a game-theoretical model and analyze how the power structure can shape the stability of an autocratic rule. If we read greater absolute power of the Ruler as conditioning more of the power and rights of the ruled on the Ruler's will, we show that a more symmetric Elite–People relationship can stabilize autocratic rule. If absolute power is stronger, this stabilizing effect will be stronger, and the Ruler's incentive to promote such symmetry will be greater. The theory explains the power structure differences between Imperial China and Premodern Europe, as well as specific institutions such as the bureaucracy in China and the role of cities in Europe. It is also consistent with the observation that autocratic rule was more stable in Imperial China than in Premodern Europe.
Keywords: No keywords provided
JEL Codes: N40; O17; P48
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| ruler's absolute power (H11) | inclusiveness of access to elite status (I24) |
| more symmetric elite-people relationship (D71) | stability of autocratic rule (D73) |
| power and rights of the people (D72) | alliance between the ruler and the people (D74) |
| more power and rights the people possess (D72) | more they lose if they defy the ruler (D73) |
| greater absolute power of the ruler (H11) | power and rights of the ruled (P14) |
| historical narratives (N01) | stability of autocratic rule in imperial China vs Europe (P16) |