Appropriate Technology Use and Autonomy: Evidence from Mexico

Working Paper: NBER ID: w27681

Authors: Carolina Corral; Xavier Gin; Aprajit Mahajan; Enrique Seira

Abstract: We explore the role of autonomy – defined as the freedom to choose how to spend an in-kind grant – in a context where farmers overuse fertilizer. We design and implement a field experiment that combines tailored input recommendations, extension services and an in-kind grant. The intervention decreased overall fertilizer use without reducing yields, reducing CO2 equivalent emissions by 14%. While autonomy did not adversely affect the adoption of recommended practices during the intervention, it led to substantially higher adoption two years after the intervention ended.

Keywords: autonomy; agricultural technology; fertilizer use; subsidies

JEL Codes: D01; O33; Q12


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
flexible grant (H77)adoption of recommended practices (Q52)
flexible grant (H77)yields (G12)
inflexible grant (H77)yields (G12)
flexible grant (H77)reduction in fertilizer use (Q16)
reduction in fertilizer use (Q16)CO2 equivalent emissions (Q54)
flexible grant (H77)persistence of practice adoption (C92)
inflexible grant (H77)persistence of practice adoption (C92)

Back to index