Coal Smoke and the Costs of the Industrial Revolution

Working Paper: NBER ID: w22921

Authors: W. Walker Hanlon

Abstract: While the Industrial Revolution brought economic growth, there is a long debate in economics over the costs of the pollution externalities that accompanied early industrialization. To help settle this debate, this paper introduces a new theoretically-grounded strategy for estimating the impact of industrial pollution on local economic development and applies this approach to data from British cities for 1851-1911. I show that local industrial coal use substantially reduced long-run city employment growth over this period. Moreover, a counterfactual analysis suggests that plausible improvements in coal use efficiency would have led to substantially higher urbanization rates in Britain by 1911.

Keywords: Industrial Revolution; Coal Pollution; Economic Development; Urbanization

JEL Codes: N13; N53; Q52; R11


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
local industrial coal use (L71)long-run city employment growth (R23)
coal use efficiency (L94)urbanization rates (R11)
pollution (Q53)location's attractiveness (R32)
pollution (Q53)worker and firm productivity (J29)
increased coal use (L94)reduced long-run employment growth (J69)

Back to index