Is Optimal Capital-Control Policy Countercyclical in Open-Economy Models with Collateral Constraints?

Working Paper: NBER ID: w22481

Authors: Stephanie Schmitt-Grohé; Martín Uribe

Abstract: This paper contributes to a literature that studies optimal capital control policy in open economy models with pecuniary externalities due to flow collateral constraints. It shows that the optimal policy calls for capital controls to be lowered during booms and to be increased during recessions. These findings are at odds with the conventional view that capital controls should be tightened during expansions to curb capital inflows and relaxed during contractions to discourage capital flight.

Keywords: capital controls; open economy models; collateral constraints; macroprudential policy

JEL Codes: E44; F41


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
positive demand shock (E00)increased collateral value (G32)
increased collateral value (G32)increased credit access (G21)
increased credit access (G21)amplifies economic expansion (F69)
negative shock (G41)decreased collateral value (G33)
decreased collateral value (G33)tightened borrowing constraints (F65)
tightened borrowing constraints (F65)deepens economic contraction (F65)
economic boom (E32)lower capital controls (F38)
recession (E32)raise capital controls (F38)

Back to index