Consolidating the Evidence on Income Mobility in the Western States of Germany and the US from 1984-2006

Working Paper: NBER ID: w18618

Authors: Gulgun Bayazozturk; Richard V. Burkhauser; Kenneth A. Couch

Abstract: The cross-national intragenerational income mobility literature assumes within-country mobility is invariant over the period measured. We argue that a great social transformation--German reunification-- abruptly and permanently altered economic mobility. Using standard measures of mobility (with panel data for the western states of Germany and the U.S.) over the entire period 1984-2006, we find the conventional result that income mobility is greater in Germany. But when we cut the data into moving five-year windows and compare mobility before and after reunification, income mobility declines significantly over the years immediately following reunification in Germany but not in the U.S.

Keywords: Income Mobility; Germany; United States; Reunification; Economic Inequality

JEL Codes: J1; J6


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
income mobility in western states of Germany (1984-1988) (J62)higher than U.S. income mobility (J62)
U.S. income mobility (1984-1988) (J62)baseline for mobility levels (J62)
U.S. income mobility (J62)stability or slight improvement in mobility (J62)
German reunification (F55)decline in income mobility in Germany (J62)
German reunification (F55)changes in income mobility (J62)
U.S. income mobility (1984-1988) (J62)decline in income mobility (1992-1996) (J62)

Back to index