Tall or Taller, Pretty or Prettier: Is Discrimination Absolute or Relative?

Working Paper: NBER ID: w18123

Authors: Daniel S. Hamermesh

Abstract: Using several microeconomic data sets from the United States and the Netherlands, and the examples of height and beauty, this study examines whether: 1) Absolute or relative differences in a characteristic are what affect labor-market and other outcomes; and 2) The effects of a characteristic change when all agents acquire more of it--become taller or better-looking. Confronted with a choice among individuals, decision-makers respond more to absolute than to relative differences among them. Also, an increase in the mean of a characteristic's distribution does not alter market responses to differences in it.

Keywords: Discrimination; Labor Market; Beauty; Height

JEL Codes: J71; J78


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
absolute differences in characteristics (C21)decision-makers' responsiveness (D70)
absolute beauty ratings (C52)likelihood of expulsion from a game show (C78)
increasing height of Dutch males (J11)earnings-height relationship (J31)
female beauty (J16)probability of charitable contributions (D64)

Back to index