The Barnett Critique After Three Decades: A New Keynesian Analysis

Working Paper: NBER ID: w17885

Authors: Michael T. Belongia; Peter N. Ireland

Abstract: This paper extends a New Keynesian model to include roles for currency and deposits as competing sources of liquidity services demanded by households. It shows that, both qualitatively and quantitatively, the Barnett critique applies: While a Divisia aggregate of monetary services tracks the true monetary aggregate almost perfectly, a simple-sum measure often behaves quite differently. The model also shows that movements in both quantity and price indices for monetary services correlate strongly with movements in output following a variety of shocks. Finally, the analysis characterizes the optimal monetary policy response to disturbances that originate in the financial sector.

Keywords: New Keynesian model; monetary aggregates; Barnett critique; liquidity services; optimal monetary policy

JEL Codes: C43; E32; E41; E52


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
divisia monetary aggregates (E19)true monetary aggregates (E19)
simple sum measures (C29)true monetary aggregates (E19)
monetary service indices (E42)output (C67)
monetary policy shocks (E39)economic output (E23)
financial sector disturbances (F65)optimal monetary policy response (E63)

Back to index