Working Paper: NBER ID: w17618
Authors: James Andreoni; Abigail Payne; Justin D. Smith; David Karp
Abstract: We explore the effects of local ethnic and religious diversity on individual donations to private charities. Using 10-year neighborhood-level panels derived from personal tax records in Canada, we find that diversity has a detrimental effect on charitable donations. A 10 percentage point increase in ethnic diversity reduces donations by 14%, and a 10 percentage point increase in religious diversity reduces donations by 10%. The ethnic diversity effect is driven by a within-group disposition among non-minorities, and is most evident in high income, but low education areas. The religious diversity effect is driven by a within-group disposition among Catholics, and is concentrated in high income and high education areas. Despite these large effects on amount donated, we find no evidence that increasing diversity affects the fraction of households that donate. Over the period studied, ethnic diversity rises by 6 percentage points and religious diversity rises by 4 percentage points; our results suggest that charities receive about 12% less in total donations. As areas like North America continue to grow more diverse over time, our results imply that these demographic changes may have significant implications for the charitable sector.
Keywords: charitable giving; ethnic diversity; religious diversity; public goods
JEL Codes: H41; J11; R23
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| Ethnic diversity (J15) | Donations (D64) |
| Religious diversity (Z12) | Donations (D64) |
| Ethnic diversity (J15) | Average donations per adult (D64) |
| Religious diversity (Z12) | Average donations per adult (D64) |
| Diversity (J15) | Total donations (D64) |