Working Paper: NBER ID: w17567
Authors: Alex Edmans; Vivian W. Fang; Emanuel Zur
Abstract: This paper studies the effect of stock liquidity on blockholders' choice of governance mechanisms. We focus on hedge funds as they are unconstrained by legal restrictions and business ties, and thus have all governance channels at their disposal. Since the threat of governance, not just actual governance, can discipline managers, we use Section 13 filings to measure governance intent rather than only studying instances of actual governance. We find that liquidity increases the likelihood that a hedge fund acquires a block in a firm. Conditional upon acquiring a stake, liquidity reduces the likelihood that a blockholder governs through voice (intervention) - as evidenced by the greater propensity to file Schedule 13Gs (passive investment) rather than 13Ds (active investment). Liquidity is more likely to lead to a 13G filing if the manager's wealth is sensitive to the stock price, consistent with governance through exit (trading). A 13G filing leads to positive announcement returns, especially in liquid firms. These two results suggest that liquidity does not dissuade blockholders from governing altogether, but instead encourages them to govern through exit rather than voice. We use decimalization as an exogenous shock to liquidity to identify causal effects.
Keywords: liquidity; blockholders; hedge funds; governance mechanisms
JEL Codes: G12; G23; G34; G38
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| liquidity (E41) | likelihood of hedge fund block acquisitions (G34) |
| liquidity (E41) | likelihood of governance through voice intervention (D72) |
| likelihood of hedge fund block acquisitions (G34) | likelihood of governance through voice intervention (D72) |
| liquidity (E41) | likelihood of filing Schedule 13G (G24) |
| liquidity (E41) | positive announcement returns for Schedule 13G filings (G14) |
| managerial sensitivity (D22) | impact of liquidity on governance choices (G33) |