Working Paper: NBER ID: w16909
Authors: Jinhu Li; Jeremiah Hurley; Philip Decicca; Gioia Buckley
Abstract: Explicit financial incentives, especially pay-for-performance (P4P) incentives, have been extensively employed in recent years by health plans and governments in an attempt to improve the quality of health care services. This study exploits a natural experiment in the province of Ontario, Canada to identify empirically the impact of pay-for-performance (P4P) incentives on the provision of targeted primary care services, and whether physicians' responses differ by age, practice size and baseline compliance level. We use an administrative data source which covers the full population of the province of Ontario and nearly all the services provided by practicing primary care physicians in Ontario. With an individual-level data set of physicians, we employ a difference-in-differences approach that controls for both "selection on observables" and "selection on unobservables" that may cause estimation bias in the identification. We also implemented a set of robustness checks to control for confounding from the other contemporary interventions of the primary care reform in Ontario. The results indicate that, while all responses are of modest size, physicians responded to some of the financial incentives but not the others. The differential responses appear related to the cost of responding and the strength of the evidence linking a service with quality. Overall, the results provide a cautionary message regarding the effectiveness of pay-for-performance schemes for increasing quality of care.
Keywords: Pay-for-Performance; Healthcare Quality; Natural Experiment
JEL Codes: I18; J33
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| P4P incentives (J33) | provision of senior flu shots (J14) |
| P4P incentives (J33) | provision of pap smears (H42) |
| P4P incentives (J33) | provision of mammograms (I18) |
| P4P incentives (J33) | provision of colorectal cancer screenings (I18) |
| P4P incentives (J33) | provision of toddler immunization (J13) |
| physician age (I11) | response to P4P incentives (J33) |
| practice size (J44) | response to P4P incentives (J33) |
| baseline compliance level (C51) | response to P4P incentives (J33) |