Working Paper: NBER ID: w15840
Authors: Anna Aizer; Laura Stroud
Abstract: We study how advances in scientific knowledge affect the evolution of disparities in health. Our focus is the 1964 Surgeon General Report on Smoking and Health - the first widely publicized report of the negative effects of smoking on health. Using an historical dataset that includes the smoking habits of pregnant women 1959-1966, we find that immediately after the 1964 Report, more educated mothers immediately reduced their smoking as measured by both self-reports and serum cotinine levels, while the less educated did not, and that the relative health of their newborns likewise increased. We also find strong peer effects in the response to information: after the 1964 report, educated women surrounded by other educated women were more likely to reduce smoking relative to those surrounded by less educated women. Over time, the education gradient in both smoking and newborn health continued to increase, peaking in the 1980s and then shrinking, eventually returning to initial levels. These results can explain why in an era of great advancements in medical knowledge, health disparities may actually increase, at least initially.
Keywords: health disparities; education; smoking; newborn health
JEL Codes: I12; I18; J13; J24
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| Education (I29) | Smoking Behavior (I12) |
| Education (I29) | Newborn Health Outcomes (I14) |
| Smoking Behavior (I12) | Newborn Health Outcomes (I14) |
| Peer Effects (C92) | Smoking Behavior (I12) |
| Education Gradient (I24) | Smoking Behavior (I12) |
| Education Gradient (I24) | Newborn Health Outcomes (I14) |
| Surgeon General's Report (I19) | Education Gradient (I24) |