Working Paper: NBER ID: w14762
Authors: Ruben Durante; Brian Knight
Abstract: This paper examines the impact of partisan control of the media on news content and viewership by consumers with differing ideologies. We use data from Italy, where the main private television network is owned by Silvio Berlusconi, the leader of the center-right coalition, and the public television corporation is largely controlled by the ruling coalition. Our first finding is that when, following the 2001 national elections, the control of the government switched from the center-left to the center-right, news content on public television shifted to the right. Second, we find evidence that viewers responded to these changes by modifying their choice of news programs. Right-leaning viewers increased their propensity to watch public channels which, even after the change, remained to the left of private channels. Furthermore, some left-wing viewers reacted by switching from the main public channel to another public channel that was controlled by the left during both periods. In line with these shifts in viewership, we also find evidence of an increase in trust in public television among right-wing viewers and a corresponding decrease among left-wing ones. Finally, we show that this behavioral response, which tended to shift ideological exposure to the left, significantly, though only partially, offset the movement of public news content to the right.
Keywords: media bias; partisan control; viewer responses; Italy; Berlusconi
JEL Codes: D7; H0
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| Partisan control of the media (D72) | News content (Y60) |
| News content (Y60) | Viewers' media consumption patterns (L82) |
| Viewers' media consumption patterns (L82) | Trust in public television (L32) |
| News content (Y60) | Trust in public television (L32) |
| Viewers' media consumption patterns (L82) | Ideological exposure of viewers (P16) |
| Ideological exposure of viewers (P16) | Net offset in ideological exposure (D63) |