Quality Competition versus Price Competition Goods: An Empirical Classification

Working Paper: NBER ID: w14305

Authors: Richard E. Baldwin; Tadashi Ito

Abstract: Based on the recent trade models of the Heterogeneous Firms Trade (HFT) model and the Quality Heterogeneous Firms Trade (QHFT) model, we classify export goods (at the HS 6-digit level of disaggregation) by quality and price competition. We find a high proportions of quality-competition goods for the major EU countries and lower proportions for Canada, Australia and China. However, the overlap of these quality-competition goods is not large, which suggests that characteristics of export goods are substantially different across countries at the same HS 6-digit code.

Keywords: quality vs price competition; heterogeneous firms trade model

JEL Codes: F14


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
type of competition (quality vs. price) (L15)characteristics of export goods (F10)
level of competition based on quality (L15)type of goods exported (F10)
comparative advantage in raw materials (F11)nature of exports (F10)
distance-price relationship (R48)differentiation between price and quality competition (L15)
characteristics of products at the same HS 6-digit level (L67)overlap of quality competition goods across countries (L15)
higher proportion of positive coefficients among EU countries (O52)prevalence of quality competition (L15)

Back to index