Working Paper: NBER ID: w13426
Authors: Bronwyn H. Hall; Grid Thoma; Salvatore Torrisi
Abstract: This paper provides novel empirical evidence on the private value of patents and R&D in European firms during the period 1991-2004. We explore the relationship between firm's stock market value, patents, and "quality"-weighted patents issued by the European Patent Office (EPO) and the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO). We find that Tobin's q is positively and significantly associated with R&D and patent stocks, but that only those patents taken out in both patent offices or at the USPTO alone seem to be valued. Either forward citations or a composite quality indicator based on forward citations, family size and the number of technical fields covered by the patent are modestly informative for value. Software patents account for a rising share of total patents in the USPTO and EPO. Moreover, some scholars of innovation and intellectual property rights argue that software and business methods patents on average are of poor quality and that these patents are applied for merely to build portfolios rather than for protection of real inventions. We found that such patents are considerably more valuable than ordinary patents, especially if they are taken out in the U.S. However their quality indicators are no more valuable than those of other patents, suggesting that their primary purpose may be to increase the size of the patent portfolio.
Keywords: patents; R&D; market value; European firms; software patents
JEL Codes: D24; G32; L86; O31; O34
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| R&D investments (O32) | Tobin's Q (G19) |
| patent stocks (O34) | Tobin's Q (G19) |
| R&D-assets ratio (O32) | Tobin's Q (G19) |
| EPO and USPTO patents (O34) | market value (D46) |
| EPO patents only (O34) | market value (D46) |
| software patents with both equivalents (L17) | market value (D46) |
| quality indicators for software patents (C88) | market value (D46) |