Working Paper: NBER ID: w12774
Authors: David Card; Dean R. Hyslop
Abstract: In the SSP Applicant Experiment, a random sample of new welfare entrants was informed that if they remained on welfare for a year they would become eligible for a generous earnings subsidy. Those who satisfied the waiting period and then left welfare and began working full time within the following year were entitled to receive payments for up to 36 months whenever they were off welfare and working full time. A simple optimizing model suggests that the program rules created an unusual sequence of incentives to: (1) prolong the initial spell on welfare for at least 12 months to become eligible for the subsidy offer; (2) establish subsidy entitlement by finding full time work and leaving welfare in the 12 to 24 month period after initial entry; and (3) choose work over welfare during the three years that subsidies were available. Consistent with these implications, comparisons between the experimental treatment group and a randomly assigned control group show that the program increased welfare participation in the first year after initial entry and lowered it over the following 5 years. We develop an econometric model of welfare participation and program eligibility status that allows us to identify the behavioral effects associated with the program rules. We find important responses to all three incentives. We also find that the impact of the program persisted after subsidy payments ended, although the effect decayed over time.
Keywords: Earnings Subsidy; Welfare Participation; Labor Market Outcomes; Self-Sufficiency Project; Canada
JEL Codes: I38
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| Eligibility incentive (I24) | Increased welfare participation (I38) |
| Eligibility incentive (I24) | Welfare participation rates (I38) |
| Establishment incentive (L26) | Rapid rate of welfare exit (I38) |
| Entitlement incentive (H55) | Full-time employment (J29) |
| Entitlement incentive (H55) | Off-welfare status (I38) |
| Program rules (Y20) | Changes in welfare participation and employment rates (I38) |
| Welfare participation rates (I38) | Labor market participation (J29) |