Dealing with Destabilizing Market Discipline

Working Paper: NBER ID: w10533

Authors: Daniel Cohen; Richard Portes

Abstract: If interest rates (country spreads) rise, debt can rapidly be subject to a snowball effect, which then becomes self-fulfilling with regard to the fundamentals themselves. This is a market imperfection, because we cannot be confident that the unaided market will choose the good equilibrium' over the bad equilibrium'. We see here a fundamental flaw in the process of market discipline. We propose a policy intervention to deal with this structural weakness in the mechanisms of international capital flows. This is based on a simple taxonomy that enables us to break down the origin of crises into three components: a crisis of confidence (spreads and currency crisis), a crisis of fundamentals (real growth rate), and a crisis of economic policy (primary deficit). The policy would seek to short-circuit confidence crises, partly by using IMF support to improve ex ante incentives.

Keywords: No keywords provided

JEL Codes: F33; F34


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
Rising interest rates (E43)self-fulfilling snowball effect on debt (F65)
self-fulfilling snowball effect on debt (F65)increased debt service burden (F34)
increased debt service burden (F34)debt crisis (F34)
Lack of confidence (D83)unfavorable economic outcomes (F69)
IMF intervention (F33)improved market discipline (G18)
IMF intervention (F33)mitigate confidence crises (H12)

Back to index