Working Paper: NBER ID: w0942
Authors: Michael Bruno
Abstract: On the basis of a comparative growth analysis of ten major industrial countries, it is shown that the productivity slowdown of the 1970s can be attributed to a combination of the energy and raw material price shocks and the contractionary macroeconomic policies that were followed in response to these shocks. For a raw material intensive sector the rise in the relative price of material inputs has lowered gross output per unit of the other complementary factors, labour and capital. For the aggregated manufacturing sector of the ten economies this explains on average about 60% of the productivity slowdown. A more disaggregated analysis for U.K. manufacturing industries is also given. On the demand side, terms of trade deterioration has reduced real income and consumption and the profit squeeze has lowered investment demand. Fear of inflation and current account deficits has imparted a further deflationary bias to aggregate demand management in most industrial countries. Depressed demand and greater output variability have hampered factor reallocation in response to the exogenous shocks. The overriding role of demand contraction, particularly in the non- manufacturing industries, is shown in a comparative analysis of the aggregate business sector and a partial view of labour productivity growth in the service industries of these economies. The industrial countries can be contrasted with the middle income developing countries where output and productivity continued to grow more evenly after 1973, at the cost of large current account deficits and higher persistent inflation. This provides further evidence that productivity growth is closely linked to macroeconomic response.
Keywords: productivity; macroeconomic response; world shocks; economic policy
JEL Codes: No JEL codes provided
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| energy and raw material price shocks (Q43) | productivity slowdown (O49) |
| rise in relative prices of material inputs (E31) | decrease in gross output per unit of labor and capital (E23) |
| contractionary macroeconomic policies (E65) | exacerbation of productivity decline (O49) |
| terms of trade deterioration (F14) | reduced real income and consumption (E21) |
| reduced real income and consumption (E21) | profit squeeze (D33) |
| profit squeeze (D33) | diminished investment demand (E22) |
| demand contraction and greater output variability (E19) | productivity slowdown (O49) |
| interaction of demand-side factors with supply shocks (E31) | productivity decline (O49) |