Working Paper: CEPR ID: DP5249
Authors: Randy Brenkers; Frank Verboven
Abstract: For a variety of reasons, it is likely that the market definition approach will remain an important tool in competition policy analysis for some time, despite the increased importance of other tools such as the simulation approach. Against the background of the new block exemption regulation for cars in Europe, we explore an econometric approach to define the relevant markets with differentiated products. On the one hand, the approach is directly consistent with the SSNIP-test, and it is in fact more satisfactory than previous approaches, such as critical elasticity analysis or the simple use of standard industry classifications. On the other hand, the approach shares a lot of features with the simulation approach (similar data requirements, and similar assumptions about current market power).We find that the relevant market for minivan cars is defined at the widest level, i.e. at the aggregate country level. Furthermore, in Italy the relevant markets for domestic cars are defined at an intermediate level, i.e. at the segment level. In all other cases, the relevant markets for cars may be defined at the narrowest level, i.e. at the subsegment level. Based on these results, we identify the firms that may violate the market share thresholds stipulated in the block exemption regulation. We find that, if we would have used an approach based on standard industry classifications instead of our econometric approach, our conclusions would have been different and, in fact, inconclusive. We also draw attention to other issues in market definition that may be of use to practitioners.
Keywords: competition policy; market definition
JEL Codes: L4; L42
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| econometric approach (C51) | market definition (G10) |
| market definition (G10) | market power (L11) |
| econometric approach (C51) | firm behavior (D21) |
| SSNIP test (H29) | market definitions (L17) |
| standard industry classifications (L80) | market definitions (L17) |
| demand substitution (D10) | competitive constraint (L13) |
| supply substitution (D10) | competitive constraint (L13) |