What We Cannot Learn from the Irish Experience: A Fundamental Asymmetry of Asymmetric Shocks

Working Paper: CEPR ID: DP2531

Authors: Fredrik Andersson; Rikard Forslid

Abstract: A simple N-country specific-factor type model with imperfectly mobile labour is developed. It is shown that the effects of country-specific productivity shocks hitting a small country are fundamentally asymmetric. A positive shock will be accommodated by a moderate wage increase and sizeable in-migration, whereas a negative shock will be accommodated by a significant decrease in wages and moderate out-migration. The effects of shocks in a monetary union are discussed, and it is argued that the results are consistent with the recent Irish experience. The welfare effects of small economic fluctuations are also discussed.

Keywords: asymmetric shocks; migration

JEL Codes: E24; F16; F22


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
positive productivity shock (O49)moderate wage increase (J38)
positive productivity shock (O49)significant immigration (F22)
negative productivity shock (O49)significant wage decrease (J31)
negative productivity shock (O49)moderate outmigration (F22)

Back to index