Working Paper: CEPR ID: DP17663
Authors: Michelle Sovinsky; Julian Hidalgo
Abstract: Inequality in access to health, education, and employment opportunities is exacerbated in developing nations due to the uneven distribution of access to high speed internet connections. In Colombia, the government enacted a policy (in 2012) to subsidize internet fees for low income households to bridge the digital divide. The reductions were not granted to all plans and thus created incentives for consumers to switch between plans. We estimate a structural model of demand for internet connection plans, which we use to quantify the importance of switching behavior. We estimate the model using data on plans offered by all internet service providers to households in all socioeconomic (SES) groups across Colombia. Our results indicate that the subsidy caused a non-negligible fraction of low-SES households to switch internet plans - the majority of which switched to plans with lower speeds not higher speeds. Furthermore, the more wealthy households (of the lower SES groups) were twice as likely to switch plans than those in the lowest SES group. Our findings suggest that the impact, not only internet adoption, but also on switching behavior should be taken into account when formulating subsidies designed to bridge the digital divide
Keywords: COVID-19; Developing Countries; Digital Divide; Internet Access; Limited Choice Sets; Consumer Switching Behaviour
JEL Codes: D12; D31; L15; L51; L86
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| Subsidy (H20) | Switching behavior (C92) |
| Subsidy (H20) | Internet adoption (L96) |
| Switching behavior (C92) | Lower-quality plans (L15) |
| Subsidy (H20) | Lower speeds (R48) |
| Market characteristics (D49) | Switching behavior (C92) |
| Wealthier households (G59) | Switching behavior (C92) |