Cultural and Public Services as Factors of City Resilience: Evidence from Big Plant Closures and Downsizing

Working Paper: CEPR ID: DP16723

Authors: Kristian Behrens; Manass Drabo; Florian Mayneris

Abstract: We combine census and establishment-level data for 2001--2017 to study the impact of big manufacturing plant closures and mass layoffs on city-level demographic changes in Canada. We find that big plant closures and mass layoffs significantly affect the composition of the cities' population. They cause a decrease in the share of residents aged 0--19 and 20--54, and an increase in the share of residents aged 55+. We also find that households with kids are more likely to stay and migrants are more likely to leave. Cities that initially have a larger population and a bigger share of their workforce in the cultural and recreational services are more resilient to large negative employment shocks. These mitigating effects are heterogeneous across age groups.

Keywords: sociodemographic change; plant closures; downsizing; manufacturing; city resilience

JEL Codes: J10; R11; R12; R23


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
plant closures (J65)decline in subsequent population growth (J11)
job loss rate (J63)decline in subsequent population growth (J11)
better initial endowments in education and health services (I24)greater resilience to negative local labor demand shocks (J69)
plant closures (J65)negative effects on employment in other sectors (F66)

Back to index