The Political Effects of Immigration: Culture or Economics?

Working Paper: CEPR ID: DP15486

Authors: Alberto Alesina; Marco Tabellini

Abstract: We review the growing literature on the political economy of immigration. First, we discuss the effects of immigration on a wide range of political and social outcomes. The existing evidence suggests that immigrants often, but not always, trigger backlash, increasing support for anti-immigrant parties and lowering preferences for redistribution and diversity among natives. Next, we unpack the channels behind the political effects of immigration. While completely separating economic from non-economic forces is impossible, we conclude that the latter are more important than the former. In examining the mechanisms, we highlight mediating factors -- such as (mis-)perceptions, the media, and the conditions under which inter-group contact occurs -- that can influence natives' reactions in different directions. Throughout the review, we outline promising avenues for future research.

Keywords: No keywords provided

JEL Codes: D72; J11; J15; J61; Z1


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
immigration (F22)backlash among natives (J15)
backlash among natives (J15)increased support for anti-immigrant parties (F55)
immigration (F22)lower preferences for redistribution among natives (J15)
immigration (F22)lower preferences for diversity among natives (J15)
unskilled immigration (K37)increased support for right-wing parties (F52)
high-skilled immigration (J61)no significant effect on support for right-wing parties (D79)
historical instances of immigration (K37)observable political shifts (P27)

Back to index