Comparative Advantage in Nonroutine Production

Working Paper: CEPR ID: DP14578

Authors: Liza Archanskaia; Johannes Van Biesebroeck; Gerald Willmann

Abstract: We illustrate a new source of comparative advantage that is generated by countries' different ability to adjust to technological change. Our model introduces substitution of workers in codifiable (routine) tasks with more efficient machines, a process extensively documented in the labor literature, into a canonical 2x2x2 Heckscher-Ohlin model. Our key hypothesis is that labor reallocation across tasks is subject to frictions, the importance of which varies by country. The arrival of capital-augmenting innovations triggers the movement of workers out of routine tasks, and countries with low labor market frictions become relatively abundant in non-routine labor. In the new equilibrium, more flexible countries specialize in producing goods that use non-routine labor more intensively. We document empirically that the ranking of countries with respect to the routine intensity of their exports is strongly related to labor market institutions and to cultural norms that influence adjustment to technological change, such as risk aversion or long-term orientation. The explanatory power of this mechanism for trade flows is especially strong for intra-EU trade.

Keywords: comparative advantage; resource allocation; routine tasks

JEL Codes: F11; F14; F15


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
Labor market frictions (J29)Comparative advantage in nonroutine tasks (D29)
Arrival of capital-augmenting innovations (O49)Movement of workers out of routine tasks (J62)
Low labor market frictions (J49)Abundance in nonroutine labor (J29)
Abundance in nonroutine labor (J29)Specialization in nonroutine labor-intensive goods (L23)
Strictness of employment protection legislation (J63)Routine specialization (Z00)
Labor market flexibility (J48)Ability to adapt to technological changes (O30)
Higher adjustment flexibility (F32)Gains from capital deepening and trade liberalization (O24)

Back to index