Working Paper: CEPR ID: DP1430
Authors: M Pilar Dfaz; Dennis J Snower
Abstract: The paper explores the influence of job security provisions on employment and unemployment. We show that this influence depends on the persistence of the macroeconomic fluctuations to which the labour market is exposed, and on employees? bargaining power in wage negotiations. Specifically, costs of firing and hiring reduce employment and stimulate unemployment when the macroeconomic fluctuations are sufficiently prolonged and employees have sufficient bargaining power; but firing and hiring costs can have the opposite effect if the fluctuations are transient and employees are weak. In this way, the paper offers an explanation for Europe?s favourable unemployment performance vis-à-vis the United States in the 1950s and 1960s (when macroeconomic fluctuations were transient and union strength was moderate), and Europe?s relatively unfavourable unemployment performance since the mid-1970s (when fluctuations were prolonged and unions were stronger).
Keywords: job security; employment; unemployment; wage determination; firing and hiring costs; macroeconomic fluctuations
JEL Codes: D8; E3; J2; J3; J6
Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.
| Cause | Effect |
|---|---|
| Hiring and firing costs (J63) | Employment (J68) |
| Hiring and firing costs (J63) | Unemployment (J64) |
| Persistence of macroeconomic fluctuations (E32) | Employment (J68) |
| Persistence of macroeconomic fluctuations (E32) | Unemployment (J64) |
| Bargaining power of employees (J52) | Employment (J68) |
| Bargaining power of employees (J52) | Unemployment (J64) |
| Prolonged macroeconomic fluctuations (E32) | Employment (J68) |
| Transient macroeconomic fluctuations (E32) | Employment (J68) |
| Prolonged macroeconomic fluctuations (E32) | Unemployment (J64) |
| Transient macroeconomic fluctuations (E32) | Unemployment (J64) |