Ease vs Noise: Long-Run Changes in the Value of Transport Disamenities

Working Paper: CEPR ID: DP13811

Authors: Gabriel Ahlfeldt; Volker Nitsch; Nicolai Wendland

Abstract: For a complete cost-benefit analysis of durable infrastructures, it is important to understand how the value of non-market goods such as transit time and environmental quality changes as incomes rise in the long-run. We use difference-in-differences and spatial differencing to estimate the land price capitalization effects of metro rail in Berlin, Germany today and a century ago. Over this period, the negative effect of rail noise tripled in percentage terms. Our results imply long-run income elasticities of the value of noise reduction and transport access of 2.2 and 1.4, substantially exceeding cross-sectional contingent valuation estimates.

Keywords: accessibility; spatial differencing; noise; difference-in-differences; income elasticity; land price

JEL Codes: R12; R14; R41; N73; N74


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
10-decibel decrease in rail noise (R41)increase in land prices (R31)
increase in incomes (E25)increase in value placed on noise reduction (Q51)
one-kilometer reduction in distance from nearest metro station (R23)decrease in capitalization effect (G31)
increase in incomes (E25)increase in income elasticity of access amenity value (R22)
metro rail accessibility (L91)increase in land prices (R31)
noise disamenities (Q53)decrease in land prices (R31)

Back to index