Financial Restrictions and Competitive Balance in Sports Leagues

Working Paper: CEPR ID: DP13154

Authors: Konstantin Sonin; Vsevolod Grabar

Abstract: A dramatic surge in revenues from TV broadcasting and brand-selling forced modern football clubs,simultaneously involved in domestic and European competitions, to operate in a new environment. Inresponse, the Union of European Football Associations introduced the Financial Fair Play Regulations, a setof financial regulations that affect all major European clubs. To assess the impact of financial restrictions(e.g., salary caps) on the default risk for individual clubs and competitive balance, we construct a game-theoreticmodel where clubs make decisions on the amounts they borrow and spend on the team. Theimpact of financial restrictions on competitive balance is positive; the total amount of debt also decreases atequilibrium. Finally, we show that financial restrictions create more incentives to invest in second-tier clubscompared to the situation in which there are no financial regulations.

Keywords: UEFA; Financial Fair Play; Financial Regulation; Competitive Balance; Investment; Tournaments

JEL Codes: D63; G28; C72


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
Financial restrictions (H60)Competitive balance (Z28)
Financial restrictions (H60)Total amount of debt across clubs (G32)
Financial restrictions (H60)Investment in second-tier clubs (Z23)
Competitive balance (Z28)Gini coefficient (decrease) (D31)

Back to index