The Effect of the H1B Quota on the Employment and Selection of Foreign-Born Labor

Working Paper: CEPR ID: DP12736

Authors: Anna Maria Mayda; Francesc Ortega; Giovanni Peri; Kevin Shih; Chad Sparber

Abstract: The H-1B program allows skilled foreign-born individuals to work in the United States. The annual quota on new H-1B issuances fell from 195,000 to 65,000 for employees of most firms in fiscal year 2004. This cap did not apply to new employees of colleges, universities, and non-profit research institutions. Existing H-1B holders seeking to renew their visa were also exempt from the quota. Using a triple difference approach, this paper demonstrates that cap restrictions significantly reduced the employment of new H-1B workers in for-profit firms relative to what would have occurred in an unconstrained environment. Employment of similar natives in for-profit firms did not change, consistent with a low degree of substitutability between H-1B and native workers. The restriction also redistributed H-1Bs toward computer-relatedoccupations, Indian-born workers, and firms using the H-1B program intensively.

Keywords: skilled workers; H1B; natural experiment

JEL Codes: J61; F22; O33; R10


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
H1B quota (J68)employment of new H1B workers in for-profit firms (J68)
H1B quota reduction (J68)employment of new H1B workers in for-profit firms (J68)
H1B quota (J68)employment of similar native workers (J68)
H1B quota (J68)redistribution of H1Bs toward occupations related to computers (L86)
H1B quota (J68)employment of Indian-born workers (J68)

Back to index