Belief Dispersion in the Stock Market

Working Paper: CEPR ID: DP12056

Authors: Adem Atmaz; Suleyman Basak

Abstract: We develop a dynamic model of belief dispersion with a continuum of investors differing in beliefs. The model is tractable and qualitatively matches many of the empirical regularities in a stock price, its mean return, volatility, and trading volume. We find that the stock price is convex in cash-flow news and increases in belief dispersion, while its mean return decreases when the view on the stock is optimistic, and vice versa when pessimistic. Moreover, belief dispersion leads to a higher stock volatility and trading volume. We demonstrate that otherwise identical two-investor heterogeneous-beliefs economies do not necessarily generate our main results.

Keywords: Asset Pricing; Belief Dispersion; Heterogeneous Beliefs; Stock Price; Mean Return; Volatility; Trading Volume; Bayesian Learning

JEL Codes: D53; G12


Causal Claims Network Graph

Edges that are evidenced by causal inference methods are in orange, and the rest are in light blue.


Causal Claims

CauseEffect
belief dispersion (D80)stock price (G12)
belief dispersion (D80)stock volatility (G17)
belief dispersion (D80)trading volume (G15)
belief dispersion (D80)mean return (C29)
risk aversion (D81)stock price (G12)
risk aversion (D81)mean return (C29)

Back to index